Please note that some posts contains affiliate links & I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links Find out More

Doggy DNA Misconceptions About Nature vs Nurture

by | Dec 4, 2022 | Dog Training & Care | 0 comments

Doggy DNA Misconceptions About Nature vs Nurture

Dog DNA tests today are popular because it influences both looks and behavior. Some dog breeds are known for specific tendencies. But socialization and training, and even mom-dog’s nurturing influence, also impact dogs.

Some dogs have to deal with a “ruff” reputation based entirely on dog dna and what breed they are – or just look like. Pit Bulls for instance seem to get lots of bad press for dog-on-dog aggression, but we also call them the “Nanny Dog” because they’re so darn good with kids. Other muscular dogs, big dogs like Rottweilers, Dobermans, German Shepherds, can get called out as aggressive, dangerous or problematic based entirely on their looks, before they ever show signs of a snarl. Of course, ALL dogs have teeth that can do damage, so understanding dog communication keeps you (and your kids) safe.

dog dna

Large group of dogs in front of a white background

Sadly, these misconceptions can lead to problems. Bigger dogs popular in the media for protection or aggression get overlooked for adoption. People miss out on glorious family companions.

As a certified animal behavior consultant and multi-published author (including a book on Pit Bulls!), I can tell you there are both myths and truths floating around about dog behavior. Both genetic and non-genetic factors influence a dog’s temperament and appearance. In fact, both nature AND nurture impact everything about your dog. Nothing is exclusive to genetics or to socialization and training.

dog dna

If you have a mixed breed dog or one with a known heritage, but want to learn more, take a look at the EMBARK DNA test. It can help identify your dog’s heritage, plus potential health issues to watch out for.

Nature vs Nurture: Does Dog DNA Matter That Much?

A dog’s behavior, personality or temperament develop from birth on, influenced by experience, training, and more. But genetics strongly influenced some doggy aspects.

For example, hip dysplasia is understood to be hereditary, but one study noted that Labrador puppies fed 25% less had a dramatically lower incidence of hip dysplasia. This is what we mean by the difference between “nature” (genetic influence) and “nurture” (environmental influence) and how they also work together.

As far as temperament, science tells us that genetics do play a role in dog behavior but they don’t entirely dictate daily behavioral traits. Every dog is an individual with individual experiences, so assuming each dog will have the traits of their parents or their breed isn’t as accurate as you might think. All dogs TEND to eat food in the same way due to dog dna genetics, but individual tendencies occur. The following are some common misconceptions that I see shared a lot, and some information debunking why they just aren’t true about our favorite Fidos:

dog dna

But…PUPPIES are so CUTE! (sorry, not a good reason..)

Common Misconceptions About Nature and Nurture

Misconception: “All that matters is how you raise them”

It’s not safe or fair to either a dog or you to lay a puppy or dog’s entire temperament upon training – although training is absolutely the best way to help dogs and their human families understand one another and live their best lives together. Most dog breeds came to be because people were purposefully attempting to breed certain characteristics for certain jobs. So dogs can’t escape every single aspect of that long, long, history of purposeful breeding.

Purpose-breeding made Border Collies genius at herding. Bloodhounds live through their noses. Labradors retrieve naturally. And these intrinsic behaviors like hunting behavior and prey drive influence many ways dogs interact with their world, making dogs like Golden Retrievers wonderful service animals, and German Shepherds excel at police work. While training can certainly steer the natural impulses of certain breeds so that we can better live and work cooperatively together, we still can’t expect that training will turn a puppy bred for high activity into a couch potato.

dog dnaMisconception: Puppies and young dogs are a “blank slate.”

Babies of any species, including humans, are not a blank slate. Maternal stressors like abuse, trauma and homelessness can have an impact on the puppies before they are even born. If you watch a new litter, you’ll quickly begin to see individual aspects of personality in each puppy. Puppies can inherit the tendency toward fear or act nervous, but socialization can help shy pups feel more confident. Remember, each being is unique and comes with their own quirks and wonders.

One of the friendliest of dogs toward people, the Pit Bull has been bred to dislike other dogs.

Misconception: You can know some dogs will be dangerous simply because of their breed.

Every day, dogs prove to us that their breed doesn’t live up to their stereotype. Some dogs historically bred for protection welcome every stranger into their home, and some dogs of a breed known to be gentle can become unpredictable and snappish based on socialization and past experiences. It’s important to understand the needs of your dog’s genetics to help them do best in life. So a high energy, highly intelligent dog that is bored is likely going to find a not so great way to occupy themself unless you give them something to occupy them. However, too many dogs get passed over in shelters because of negative stereotypes created by the media that have no basis in fact.

Should you have concerns, look at adopting senior dogs. Adopting an older dog you will more likely have a history, and be better informed as to what the personality type is of the pet you are adopting.

prevent dog bites with common sense

Don’t tempt fate! How stooopid is this?

Misconception: A good dog is always a good dog.

We all have bad days. You have a bad day at work, and “snap” at your kids when you come home. Somebody cuts us off in traffic and we take it out on the cashier at the drive through. “Good” dogs can have bad days, too, which is why it is important for dog parents to take the time to learn about canine body language.

Always supervise dogs with children. Just as we humans can’t really know how we’ll react in a crisis, we can’t be sure how our dog will react if they are injured or frightened.

dog dna

Misconception: If a dog is “bad” it’s because they have lousy socialization or training.

Sadly, some dogs are born “broken” just as some people develop emotional, psychological, or health issues through no fault of their own. With help from a veterinary behaviorist and proper medication, you can sometimes moderate some of these problems.

But you can’t train away or completely “fix” an abnormal chemical reaction that starts in the brain. Please do not blame, punish yourself–or others–who struggle with one of these dogs. Sometimes there’s no simple answer with dangerous behavioral issues. Dogs (and the people who love them) shouldn’t be forced to put up with a dangerous or emotionally painful situation, so talk with your vet for advice.

dog dna

So where does a doggy’s nature end and nurture begin?

We’d love to say it’s easy to tell, but the fact is, a dog’s temperament and innate behaviors are complex. It certainly helps – and is fun – to research your dog’s breed background, for insight into their behavior and possible natural strengths. Some of those strengths – for example the historically quick mind of a Belgian Malinois – will mean you have a responsibility to be prepared to provide extra mental stimulation and physical activity to meet those “natural” needs. If your Malinois mix grows up to be a gentle goof instead – at least they’ll be a well-trained goof instead of a bored, destructive Einstein!

We should give every dog the very best opportunity to grow from a puppy into a well-adjusted adult dog. Good nutrition, thoughtful socialization, and learning opportunities that keep their minds engaged. Every dog deserves help in learning to navigate what humans expect of them – no matter what breed they happen to be – or just look like.

Are you dealing with a behavior challenge with your dog, or need help to understand what your dog is trying to tell you? You can find general answers to LOTS of pet questions here on the blog (just type the topic in the SEARCH bar at the top). You also can find more detailed answers in one of my award-winning dog books. And if you’re struggling, here’s how to find professional behavior help.

YouTube Button

I love hearing from you, so please share comments and questions. Do you have an ASK AMY question you’d like answered? Do you have a new kitten and need answers? Stay up to date on all the latest just subscribe the blog, “like” me on Facebook, and sign up for Pet Peeves newsletter. Stay up to date with the latest book giveaways and appearances related to my September Day pet-centric THRILLERS WITH BITE!

Amy Shojai, CABC is a certified cat & dog behavior consultant, a consultant to the pet industry, and the award-winning author of 35+ pet-centric books and Thrillers with Bite! Oh, and she loves bling!


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Recent Posts

New Year Book Bundle: 7 Hardcover Thrillers, Anyone?

Enter for a chance to WIN all 7 September & Shadow Thrillers–in hardcover.

Yes, you can purchase them from my bookstore at a discount. But you can enter the giveaway contest for free, and then “gift” the paw-tographed books to yourself–or someone who loves pet-centric stories.

The more you share the contest, the greater your chance to win. Fill out the form, and start sharing. Good luck!

Update on Cyprus Cats: New FIP Strain Identified

This past summer I reported on the apparent FIP outbreak among cats on the island of Cyprus. As thousands of cats quickly sickened and died from signs of feline infectious peritonitis (FIP), experts puzzled over why. While the feline-specific illness tragically kills most infected cats (if not given expensive hard-to-access treatment), pockets of “outbreaks” had previously been limited to handfuls of cats in cattery or shelter population.

But in Cyprus, things changed. Here’s the update…stranger than fiction, but true.

How To Give Pets As Gifts

Giving pets as gifts prompts discussions every time the subject comes up. Most recently, we got our “gift puppy” and “gift kitten” when they adopted us, and we’re so glad Karma-Kat and Shadow-Pup are part of our holidays. But for many folks, this year means a new puppy or new kitten for Christmas. Learn how to gift pets–and please share your experiences in the comments!

The professionals used to say that the holidays were a TERRIBLE time to get a new pet–that impulse adoptions could leave the cat or dog without a home after the cute-holiday-thrills wore off. More recently, though, the ASPCA conducted some surveys and discovered that when done properly, these adoptions can be lasting, loving adoptions. So I had to re-think my advice.

Holidays tend to be hectic times when normal routines go out the window. Whether a baby, adult, or senior rescue cat or dog, new animals need the stability of knowing what to expect. In fact, some holiday schedules may allow you to be home more during this time to help the new kitty or pooch adjust.

Holiday pets take more work, true. But just think: you’re not only giving the pet to a person—you’re giving a special human to a waiting cat or dog, a fur-kid hungry for a loving, permanent home. Happy holidays, indeed!

Mystery Canine Respiratory Disease? What We Know

Each fall and winter heralds a rise in respiratory illnesses in people–and also in dogs. Like humans, dogs can contract a number of hacking, wheezing, coughing, yucky illnesses that make them feel bad. Canine respiratory diseases get lumped together as canine infectious respiratory disease complex (CIRDC). These are a constellation of different illnesses resulting from viral, fungal, or bacterial infections.

One of the most common, kennel cough, spreads easily from dog to dog. It gets its name because dogs housed closely together in kennels, boarding facilities, shelters, and similar places provide the perfect transmission opportunity. But recently, an apparent increase in dog respiratory disease has owners, and many vets concerned.

13 Pet Holiday Dangers to Avoid: How to Keep Cats & Dogs Safe

I write about pet holiday dangers every year. This listicle (and a fun infographic at the bottom) offers more than a dozen problems. I’ve included links to more detailed information for those wanting a deeper dive on all the must-knows for pet holiday safety!

Merry Cat-Mas & Doggy Ho-Ho-Ho! Here’s How to Create a Tree for the Pets

Have you decked the halls yet with your howl-iday decor? What do the pets think? Have they joined in the spirit of ho-ho-ho and wreaked havoc? Or do they ignore the festivities?

The Christmas tree might as well be an early holiday gift to your cats and dogs. Pets can’t resist the urge to sniff, claw, water—and scale the branches to reach the highest possible perch. Don’t blame your cat or dog. It’s normal for cats to compete for the top spot (literally and figuratively) to secure their place in kitty society, and dogs may want to “mark” the convenient indoor doggy signpost.

Protect your precious memories by pet-proofing to prevent breakage (yes, this happened to me!) And give your pets something “legal” to enjoy. Here’s how to create pet safe holiday fun for cats and dogs.

Playing Around…in SISTER ACT Musical!

From time to time, I’m blessed to participate in the local community theater productions. Sometimes, that means playing cello or keyboard in the loft, and other times, onstage. This month, I’m “playing around” as Sister Mary Martin-of-Tours, a nun in SISTER ACT musical. We open Friday December 1 and run three weekends (Thursday-Sunday matinee) through December 17th.

Cat Books Sale: “When you get a cat, there should be 4 requirements by law:

I was born to love pets & spread JOY! My books bring smiles, save lives, and reduce vet bills. So I put ALL MY CAT BOOKS ON SALE…cuz maybe you’ll want to “adopt” more of my 35+ award-winning pet books or share the purr-fect love with other pet lovers.

You can get ’em for full price on Amazon, BUT…

Dog Books Sale: “One of the best I have read…”

I was born to love pets & spread JOY! My books bring smiles, save lives, and reduce vet bills. So I put ALL MY DOG BOOKS ON SALE…cuz maybe you’ll want to “adopt” more of my 35+ award-winning pet books or share the purr-fect love with other pet lovers.

You can get ’em for full price on Amazon, BUT…

Counting Thanksgiving Blessings, the Pet Writer Way in 2023

Time for my annual Count My Blessings post. The past year has meant change, change, and more change, and that’s good and also challenging. But some things never change…I’m thankful to you—yes, those who read this blog, the cat book lovers, and the dog book lovers, and folks who have “adopted” my thriller series. And those who offered awesome applause and support any of the other venues mentioned…

Visit Amy's Website

Amy Shojai CACB is an award winning author.  You can find all her publications and book her to speak via her website. 

On Demand Writer Coaching is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to