Please note that some posts contains affiliate links & I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links Find out More

Ask Amy Shojai: Cat Clawing & H...
Ask Amy Shojai: Cat Clawing & How to Train

Woof Wednesday: Putting On the Dog at Dog Shows

by | Feb 22, 2012 | Dog Training & Care | 15 comments

Last week, I’m sure a number of readers watched the Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show on television. I’ve attended this event several times–I shot most of the pictures in today’s blog at Westminster–and it’s even more exciting and impressive in person.

In an email communication that mentioned the show, though, one passionate pet advocate expressed the hope that folks NOT watch the show. A finger was pointed at shows for promoting the sale of pets for profit, labeling the practice to be cruelty to animals that created the need for rescue organizations and shelters to deal with the cast offs.

[caption id=”” align=”aligncenter” width=”431″ caption=”This Standard Poodle is not yet ready for his close-up! Again, taken in the benching area at Westminster.” White poodle in show wraps


Wow. I have to applaud the passion, and I actually agree with some of the comments. I also would like to see an end to the need for rescue and shelters, but I don’t believe banning dog shows (or cat shows) would stop indiscriminate breeding. Just take a look in the paper at the “free puppies” section—those are not dog show animals being bred for profit. Punishing the folks who research pedigrees, perform expensive genetic and other health tests before doggy match-making, fund ultrasounds, support research to improve health of all dogs (or cats) doesn’t account for numbers found in rescue, foster and shelter organizations. I know many breeders who include in their contract that should your circumstances change THEY will take back the dog or cat.

The only folks who actually make money breeding dogs and cats would never get one of their dogs into Westminster or a comparable show. If you heard my colleague David Frei comment during the broadcast, you learned that a majority of the exhibitors at these high-venue events are ALSO into rescue work, support shelters, do therapy dog work, visit prisons, are hunting dogs or SAR emergency teams, and help fund health studies that benefit all dogs and cats including shelter animals.

[caption id=”” align=”aligncenter” width=”432″ caption=”Corded coats as on this Komondor served to protect the dogs as herders, but critics suggest the emphasis on appearance may not be good for the dogs.” komondor


What’s the deal with showing dogs, anyway? The earliest record of a dog show dates to June 1859 in England and featured hunting dogs, while today the show world has expanded to include a much greater variety of breeds, types, and fun canine sports.

Learn about conformation dog shows here. are the beauty contest of the dog world, like the Westminster show. But conformation goes beyond simple looks. Show judges must know what constitutes the breed “ideal” and measure each competing canine against that mind’s eye image to select the winner that comes closest. Besides looks, the dog’s health, ability to move, and even personality must be up to snuff.


Interestingly, after the 2012 Westminster winning Pekingese Malachy was crowned, quite a bit of outcry resulted not only from folks like rescue and shelter organizations, but also from those in the “show” world. You see, dog shows have a public relations problem—as evidenced by the comments that prompted this column. The breeding of some dogs to extravagant extremes that meets a “show” standard but may impact the health and well- being of the dog has been in question for years, from veterinarians and forward-thinking dog lovers. While the Peke breed was developed to be a lap dog/pet in ancient China, and the winner certainly fit today’s standard, the little guy epitomized all the complaints about purebred dog breeding favoring form over function. The coat alone would be crippling and lethal in a Texas summer!

Thank you to everyone who does their part for companion pets everywhere. It shouldn’t be an “us against them” mentality. I just wish that all the “good guys” from every arena—show, shelter, rescue, feral TNR, foster and more—worked together for the mutual benefit and against the common enemy—abuse, neglect, and more.

I love hearing from you, so please share comments and questions. Do you have an ASK AMY question you’d like answered? Stay up to date on all the latest just subscribe the blog, “like” me on Facebook, listen to the weekly radio show, check out weekly PUPPY CARE must knows, and sign up for Pet Peeves newsletter with pet book give-aways!


  1. Lorie Huston, DVM

    Well said, Amy. I get a bit disturbed by the “us against them” mentality also. Like you, I don’t believe it’s the breeders who show up at Westminster and other dog shows that are breeding the majority of the puppies that end up in shelters and rescues. Let’s point that finger where it belongs…at the puppy mills and the pet stores that support them. And at the public who not only buys those puppies but looks at pets as disposable commodities.

    I do think a great deal of controversy surrounding this year’s Westminster show centered around the Westminster Kennel Club decision to drop Pedigree as a sponsor. And I agree that some breeds are being bred to their detriment. The Peke is only one example of that.

    • amyshojai

      Thanks Lorie. Yes, lots of ill feelings re: the Pedigree sponsorship and very bad timing on their part. Purina is a great supporter of dog shows and perhaps a better partner but–gee, PR 101 says you don’t stir up bad mojo before a major event!

      And yes, the Peke is an obvious example and there are others. But also there are breeds where certain health issues have been identified and virtually eliminated because of meticulous breeders. Shades of gray…(or merle? *s*)

  2. Tameri Etherton

    Shades of merle! That’s funny.

    I’m not into the whole dog show scene, so I didn’t know all of this was going on behind the scenes, but I have to say – anytime there is an ‘us vs them’ attitude, there are no winners.

    Having said that, I do like to watch the Westminister show to see all the crazy dog breeds I’ve never heard of. Like that moppy kind of dog – they crack me up.

    Thanks for the info, Amy. It will be interesting to see what happens next.

    • amyshojai

      Oh Tameri, you would not believe all that goes on “behind the scenes” LOL! If you ever get the chance to see the movie BEST IN SHOW, watch–it’s laugh out loud funny, pokes fun at dog shows and…it’s true. Well, maybe not the two left feet but the rest is so on the money it’s scary.

      • Tameri Etherton

        I did see that movie – it has that actress whose name escapes me, but she’s so funny. I think I’ll get it again just for the laughs.

  3. Joy Held's Writer Wellness Blog

    I always wondered where the doggies did the “business” in NYC at Westminster.

    • amyshojai

      Hi Joy, it’s a roped off area in the benching section with sawdust. *s* Some of those pictures were taken right outside the potty area, because there’s a blank wall (for less background clutter) and the dogs taking a break aren’t as inclined to be in a rush to a ring.

  4. Karyl Cunningham

    You’ve pretty much already said anything I would have said here, so if you will forgive my totally unrelated happy moment: we had a win this week for Ohio dogs!

    Wondering what’s up with the police dog bit but I ASSUME it’s a caveat noting dogs that are doing those things in defense of the officer in the line of duty, since no police K-9 program I know of would let in an unstable dog. They’d never make it past training.

    But hooray for pit bulls not being legally seen as monsters! I know there will still be bias from individuals and towns, but it’s a step in the right direction.

    • amyshojai

      Hi Karyl, Yes, I saw that notice about the change to the Ohio definition of “vicious dog” and that they’d removed the Pit Bull breed. YAY! Finally some sense! And yes, regarding the police dog issue–those dogs are trained to bite/attack on command so with such a broad definition of “vicious” they had to make that change.

      With the current definition of my Magical-Dog bit a thief breaking into my house, he’d be “defined” by the Ohio law as vicious even though he’d be protecting his/my property. That’s a problem with broad-based black-and-white laws but thank goodness Columbus has at least given the nod to the fact it’s not a breed-specific thing but a behavior issue (dog & human).

      • Karyl Cunningham

        Yeah I have to admit I find that a bit odd, that if the dog is protecting your home it still counts as “vicious”… we have castle doctrine in Ohio. If someone breaks in I can use lethal force. Why can’t my dog? Not that most dogs are trained to kill, mostly just hold, but still… I can shoot the intruder but my dog can’t bite him? Seems silly.

        • amyshojai

          Karyl, you’re absolutely right. Same here in Texas with regard to self protection/defense.

  5. Karen Nichols

    Best in Show is one of my favorite movies. I think it’s wrong to condemn those who show at Dog/Cat shows. I’ve met a lot of people at cat shows who are passionate about their animals, not people running breeding mills. I rarely tell anyone that I own some purebreds because of the backlash I’m likely to get for that, which is insane.

    • amyshojai

      Hi Karen, thanks for the comment! Yes, I get some raised eyebrows, too, with Magic. Not so much with Seren since she’s just a Siamese “wannabe.” Dog and cat overpopulation is a complicated issue that can’t be solved (or blamed) on single situations or else it would have been solved long ago. The trend for “designer breeds” IMO has done more to impact the plight of dogs in rescues/shelters than purebred/pedigree shows.

  6. Marion Spicher

    My sister-in-law breeds, raises and shows golden retrievers in Canada.

    Dogs are her passion. They currently have six golden retrievers in a private home in the city. But she takes them to the country and runs them every day. My mother used to say if she had to come back after death, she wanted to come back as one of my sister-in-law’s dogs.

    Years ago, my husband ran his Labradors in field trials, which measured their performance at following hand signals, obedience, marking and retrieving etc. as working hunting dogs. I had my complaints watching him train the dogs. But the working dogs are bred to hone their hunting skills, and not their looks. Although looks do enter the picture. Once he decided it was rather like the odds in a horse race, he ceased the expensive entry fees, and now simpoy enjoys our dogs that accompany him on the hunting fields.

    • amyshojai

      Hi Marion, I love the Goldens and the Labs! The field trial dogs due to emphasis on performance even LOOK different than many of the conformation dogs, and it’s a joy to see a truly engaged hunting dog work his magic. I also have problems–great issues–with SOME of the training techniques employed by the hunting dog folks (E-stim collars are the subject for another blog 🙁 ) but am pleased to say the training trend has turned to kinder, more effective means today.

      And I love your analogy about the odds in a horse race. The entry fees are expensive, the travel is expensive, “campaigning” a dog can be stressful and again, expensive. The dogs that make it to Westminster and other high-profile shows have been funded to the tune of thousands of dollars. It will be the economy that derails shows, not other issues . . .


Leave a Reply


Recent Posts

National Pet Wellness Month & How Cats And Dogs Impact Our Lives

October is National Pet Wellness Month which celebrates caring for our pets. That means you’ll want to:

👨‍⚕️ Schedule a visit with your veterinarian
🆘 Watch your pet’s weight
🥎 Don’t skip exercise
👌 Keep up-to-date with pet prevention
🐾 Invest in pet insurance

For those who adore cats and dogs or other critters, our animal companions impact us in so many ways we can’t imagine living in a world without them. That begs the questions, how (and why) pets are so important to us. I covered this a bit in what makes people happy, but wanted to go beyond that post.

The Love Connection

As social creatures, humans crave companionship. We are tactile beings, relishing contact with others. During the COVID pandemic, with opportunities for human contact curtailed, our pets became even more important. While we couldn’t reach out and touch each other, petting a beloved dog or cat, horse or hamster filled up our empty emotional tanks with the love we need to thrive and survive…


It’s Adopt A Dog Month! If a new fur-kid is in your future, remember that more goes into adopting a dog than picking the “prettiest” or just plopping food in a bowl. I’ve written about shelter adoptions before, but here are more specific tips. Follow these do’s and don’ts to ensure your furry love connection lasts past the honeymoon and endures for the lifetime of that pet.

10 DO’s & DON’Ts for Adopting a Dog (or Cat)

Don’t adopt too early. Kittens and puppies adopted too young bite and claw more than those corrected by Mom and siblings. Wait to adopt furry until they are at least 8-10 weeks old for pups and 12 to 16 weeks for kittens…

What Makes Humans Happy? And Where Do Pets Fit In?

When we look at the principles of Positive Psychology (the study of what human wellbeing and fulfillment is made of – including happiness) it’s easy to see why so many of us attribute our happiness and wellness to our pets! I’ve frequently written about how pets show love, and what dogs want out of life. So why not explore what makes humans happy, too?

Read on to learn about th 5 Elements of Human Well-being According to Positive Psychology…

How to Prepare for a Disaster: Pet Preparedness & Tips

With the latest hurricane and more on the way, it’s time to revisit your pet disaster plan. You do have one, right? After Katrina and Harvey, everyone should understand the importance of disaster preparation.

I posted this in June for National Pet Preparedness Month. September is Disaster Preparation Month. Hurricane Ian drives home the importance of having a disaster plan not only for yourself when Mother Nature throws a tantrum but also to keep your pets safe. Whether you must deal with tornadoes, floods, landslides, typhoons, wildfires, or other emergencies, there’s a rule that we must always PLAN FOR THE WORST.

And then pray it doesn’t happen. For those going through issues now, refer to these resources:

Florida Animal Shelter Emergency Response
Mobile Phone: 941-525-8035.
Office Phone: 863-577-4605.

Florida Animal Shelter Emergency Response

American Humane Red Star Disaster Response

American Red Cross

Disaster Assistance and Emergency Relief (Government)

What Cats Want Out of Life & What Cats Need

Whether you share your pillow with a kitty, or care for feral, stray or community cats, always consider what cats want out of life. I’ve written about what makes humans happy, as well as what dogs want out of life, and it’s time for the cats. We love our cats all year long, but sometimes lose sight of what cats need out of life. It’s important to channel your “inner kitty” to learn how to keep the purrs rumbling 24/7 to provide what cats need.

Dark Mystery, Thriller & Suspense Books Galore! Booksweeps Giveaway, Emily Kimelman & More!

👀 I spy a steal…If you haven’t read my first September & Shadow Thriller, you can enter to win it on BookSweeps today — plus 55 exciting Dark Mysteries, Thrillers & Suspense books from a great collection of authors… AND a brand new eReader 😀

I’ve teamed up with fantastic authors to give away a huge collection of mysteries and suspense thrillers to 2 lucky winners!

Oh, and did I mention the Grand Prize winner gets a BRAND NEW eReader? 😁

Adopting “Other-Abled” and Less Adoptable Pets

September 19-25 is National Adopt A Less Adoptable Pet Week, founded by The organization encourages shelters and rescues to create special week-long events devoted to giving overlooked pets like those with disabilities a better chance at finding homes.

This struck a chord with me, especially after living with a tri-pawd dog when Bravo lost his leg. He didn’t act disabled, though. Have you ever adopted an other-abled pet or less adoptable pet?

What Is A Less Adoptable Pet

Why less adoptable? They’re the wrong breed or have special needs. Overlooked pets include deaf dogs or deaf cats, blind pets, or those missing a limb. Many folks prefer the ‘perfect’ cute puppy or kitten and don’t want a crippled pet, or just don’t like the color of the dog or cat. Of course, we know black dogs and cats, and those with only one eye, or three legs, still love us with all their furry hearts! Read on…

Do Pets See In Color?

I love this question. What do you think? Today’s Ask Amy topic is Do dogs see in color? What about cats and dogs, do they see things differently?

Today, take a fun look at this YouTube video discussing the question. And weigh in with your own thoughts in the comments–does color matter to your fur kids?

How to Manage Fur Shedding

When dog shedding and cat shedding creates hairy tumbleweeds, it creates a fur-ocious mess you need to manage. At one time, our German Shepherd Magic’s fur shedding turned our cream carpet to gray. Today we live with two short-haired pets. But Karma-Kat’s silver fur and the Shadow-Pup’s undercoat become furry dust mice on the kitchen’s slate floor, float through the air, and cling to upholstery and clothing. Knowing what to do goes beyond keeping the house clean. Proper fur care can prevent skin problems and also help manage hairballs.

Exposure to sunlight or artificial light determines the timing and amount of shedding. “It is a normal process which can be accelerated under certain circumstances,” says Steven Melman, VMD, an internationally known expert on veterinary dermatology and the founder of In fact, indoor pets exposed to artificial light shed nonstop, even during triple-digit summer or frigid winter months.

Whatever time of year shedding occurs, it’s aggravating, and a nonstop cleaning challenge. Why do pets shed fur, and how can we manage the mess?

DON’T Hug Your Dog on National Hug Your Hound Day! Here’s Why

Several years ago when I wrote for the site (now TheSprucePets) I took issue with a promotion advertised by a big-name pet food company that encouraged people to post pictures of themselves hugging dogs. Hoo-boy…Oh dear heaven, by the comments I received you’d think that I said cute babies are evil, apple pie is poison and advocated BEATING YOUR DOG! Part of that has to do with folks reading only the title and ignoring the content of the message. Oh well. That drives home the importance of titles, I suppose.

The promo really struck a chord with pet lovers. After all, who doesn’t love a hug? Hugs mean love, hugs mean happy happy happy, hugs are tail-wagging expressions of the joy we share with dogs. Right? RIGHT?!

Uh, no. And glory be, the promotion lives on, declaring September 11 as “Hug Your Hound Day.” Before you tar-and-feather me, read on to learn WHY hugging your dog can put you, and your dog, in danger…

Visit Amy’s Website

Amy Shojai CACB is an award winning author.  You can find all her publications and book her to speak via her website. 

On Demand Writer Coaching is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to



Pin It on Pinterest

Share This